Senior Director, Total Rewards

Credit Acceptance•Bellevue, WA
•$262,800 - $306,600

About The Position

Credit Acceptance is seeking an accomplished Total Rewards leader to rethink the function from first principles and design purpose-built solutions aligned with business outcomes. The role brings deep compensation expertise and leads benefits and payroll, maintaining accuracy, compliance, and reliability while transforming programs, processes, and systems. Success means enabling better decisions, a simpler and more valuable experience, and continuous improvement. The Senior Director will define Total Rewards strategy and philosophy; lead executive compensation, base pay, merit, incentive, and equity programs; and advise senior executives on complex compensation decisions, including recommendations for the Board’s Compensation Committee. The leader will evaluate existing programs, policies, processes, vendors, and systems, using data, technology, automation, and AI to simplify work and improve controls. The role also oversees compensation, benefits, payroll, and equity administration, compliance, benefits sustainability, budgets, vendors, and technology investments. The role builds and leads a high-performing Total Rewards team and partners across HR, Finance, Legal, Technology, and business leadership. It calls for sound judgment, evidence-based recommendations, experimentation, and the ability to translate complex technical, financial, and regulatory matters into clear executive choices. Targeted compensation is $262,800–$306,600 in base salary plus an annual bonus plan.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree from an accredited institution in an analytical or technical field.
  • 10+ years of progressive Total Rewards experience, with deep expertise in compensation strategy, design, and governance.
  • Direct experience designing executive compensation, annual incentive and merit programs, and long-term incentive or equity programs, including public company governance.
  • Demonstrated success redesigning compensation strategy, structures, and programs and leading complex change, such as policy simplification or technology modernization, with measurable results.
  • Proven success building and leading teams of functional specialists, including developing leaders, with sufficient benefits and payroll knowledge to lead and oversee those disciplines.
  • Strong financial, analytical, and regulatory judgment; ability to use data, technology, and structured problem-solving to improve decisions and simplify operations; and executive presence to present recommendations to CEOs, CFOs, CHROs, and board committees.

Nice To Haves

  • Relevant professional certifications, such as CCP, CEBS, or CPP.
  • Experience in financial services, consumer lending, or another regulated industry.
  • Experience leading technology-enabled transformation, such as systems modernization, vendor changes, or operating model redesign.
  • Familiarity with HR and payroll platforms, including Workday and ADP.
  • Experience presenting to a board compensation committee.
  • Experience designing rewards and incentives that balance growth, profitability, risk, and long-term enterprise value.

Responsibilities

  • Define a Total Rewards philosophy and strategy tied to business priorities and talent needs, with principles for pay competitiveness, internal equity, and performance differentiation.
  • Lead the design of executive compensation, base pay, merit, short- and long-term incentives, and equity programs.
  • Advise senior executives on complex compensation decisions, including analysis and recommendations for the Board’s Compensation Committee.
  • Evaluate programs, policies, processes, vendors, and systems and determine what to preserve, improve, redesign, or discontinue.
  • Develop purpose-built solutions using policy, process, technology, data, human expertise, automation, and AI; remove unnecessary policies, approvals, and complexity.
  • Set hypotheses and measures of success, deliver improvements incrementally, and build resilient systems that reduce manual dependencies and strengthen controls.
  • Lead compensation, benefits, payroll, and equity administration with accuracy, timeliness, security, strong controls, backup coverage, and continuity planning.
  • Ensure compliance with federal, state, and local requirements, including wage and hour, payroll tax, ERISA, ACA, and securities disclosure, in partnership with Legal, Finance, and Internal Audit; support Compensation Committee materials.
  • Own benefits design and sustainability, Total Rewards budgets, vendors, and technology investments.
  • Build and lead a high-performing Total Rewards team with deep expertise, strong functional leaders, and clear accountability.
  • Determine what capabilities to build internally and what to source externally; foster curiosity, constructive challenge, and experimentation.
  • Partner with HR, Finance, Legal, Technology, and business leaders, translating complex technical, financial, and regulatory issues into clear choices for executives.
  • Remain compliant with company policies, processes, and legal guidelines; perform other duties as assigned; meet attendance requirements as required by the department.

Benefits

  • 401(K) match
  • Adoption assistance
  • Parental leave
  • Tuition reimbursement
  • Comprehensive medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • Annual bonus plan
  • Other nonstandard benefits
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service