Senior Counsel

Berkley•Scottsdale, AZ
•Hybrid

About The Position

Nautilus Insurance Group is seeking a Senior Counsel for its Scottsdale office on a hybrid basis. The role provides thoughtful and effective legal counsel to the Claims Department and manages extra-contractual exposures arising from property and casualty claims across the United States. It includes reviewing certain coverage positions recommended by Claims staff and leadership, advising on severe and sensitive exposures, and providing general legal support to other departments as needed. The Senior Counsel also facilitates and participates in projects and training, and helps identify ways to responsibly use artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies while meeting legal, ethical, and regulatory requirements. The successful candidate can work autonomously and collaboratively, communicates professionally with internal and external business partners, and brings strong insurance coverage and litigation management skills. The position calls for sound professional judgment, strong practice and time-management skills, and the ability to prioritize inquiries and matters effectively. Occasional travel may be required, and reasonable, regular, predictable attendance is expected.

Requirements

  • J.D. degree.
  • Admission in good standing to practice law in at least one U.S. jurisdiction.
  • At least seven years of experience managing litigation and/or providing coverage advice, including at least three years related to property and casualty insurance coverage, claims, and coverage litigation.
  • Strong interpersonal communication skills and ability to work with different personality types to achieve desired results.
  • Working knowledge of privacy and confidentiality laws and regulations, and ability to handle confidential information.
  • Proficient research skills; ability to analyze and resolve complex situations; sound judgment and decision-making; attention to detail; and strong prioritization and organizational skills.
  • Good knowledge of computer applications in a Windows environment, including Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Teams, and email.
  • Ability to work with minimal supervision.
  • Reasonable, regular, predictable attendance.
  • Occasional travel may be required.

Nice To Haves

  • Excess and Surplus Lines insurance experience.

Responsibilities

  • Provide thoughtful counsel and strategic guidance concerning high-severity, complex, and sensitive claims.
  • Review and approve coverage correspondence, including select reservation-of-rights, tender-denial, and disclaimer letters.
  • Facilitate consistency in coverage positions.
  • Communicate and present legal and business issues to staff and leadership throughout the organization.
  • Provide counsel concerning risk management.
  • Proactively manage extra-contractual litigation.
  • Facilitate the coordination and collection of information and documentation for discovery.
  • Assist Claims Department staff and leadership with outside vendor relationships.
  • Responsibly leverage AI and other technology tools.
  • Maintain awareness of developments and trends in case law, statutes, regulations, and judicial climate.
  • Work with business partners to draft and interpret policy forms.
  • Provide timely training to Claims Department staff.
  • Attend mediations, trials, and depositions as necessary.
  • Perform other duties as required.

Benefits

  • Paid childbirth recovery and primary caregiver leave, up to a maximum of 12 weeks.
  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage options.
  • Flexible Spending Account and Health Savings Account choices.
  • 401(k) program.
  • Profit sharing.
  • Stock purchase plan.
  • Life insurance and travel accident insurance options.
  • One paid day off per year to volunteer at a local charity.
  • Tuition assistance and industry-related education and exam programs.
  • Special cell phone service discounts with Verizon and AT&T.
  • Cost-free access to travel and entertainment discounts through the Plum Benefits program.
  • Flexible work arrangements.
  • On-site fitness center available free to employees; yoga and other classes available for a nominal fee.
  • Competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full-time regular employees.

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Senior

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service