Personal Lines Manager

Horst Group • Lancaster, PA

1d • Hybrid

About The Position

Horst Insurance is dedicated to providing legendary insurance services to its clients. From our team approach to providing unique services and resources, Horst Insurance has one simple goal, to become our client's trusted insurance advisor. Horst Insurance provides commercial and personal insurance services and employee group benefits to over 7,500 businesses and families in Pennsylvania, Maryland, and Delaware. The Personal Lines Manager leads the Personal Lines department, driving sales growth, client retention, service excellence, operational efficiency, and team development. This role oversees daily operations and works with producers, account managers, carriers, and senior leadership to support profitable growth and outstanding client service.

Requirements

• A four-year college degree or equivalent; plus, specialized training or education in insurance.
• At least five years of management experience, and 10 years of insurance experience preferred.
• All relevant work experience will be considered.
• Must hold a PA Producer License.
• Leadership, coaching, mentoring, and team development
• Client service, relationship management, and issue resolution
• Personal lines insurance knowledge and coverage consultation
• Sales growth, account rounding, cross-selling, and retention strategy
• Workflow management, operational planning, and process improvement
• Analytical thinking, problem solving, and sound decision-making
• Professional communication with clients, carriers, producers, employees, and leadership

Responsibilities

• Lead the Personal Lines department in achieving goals for client retention, service quality, sales support, account rounding, revenue growth, operating efficiency, and profitability.
• Develop and implement sales growth initiatives and identify creative opportunities to expand the Personal Lines book of business.
• Manage daily department operations, workflows, staffing needs, workloads, and service standards to ensure timely and accurate handling of new business, renewals, endorsements, cancellations, billing questions, claims support, and client inquiries.
• Supervise, coach, and support Personal Lines account managers, account administrators, and related team members, including hiring, onboarding, training, performance feedback, workload management, and professional development.
• Evaluate team performance, set objectives and standards, and address performance concerns in alignment with company policies and expectations.
• Resolve escalated client or carrier issues and provide guidance on coverage, policy changes, billing, claims, and risk management needs.
• Perform all other duties as assigned by insurance leadership.

Benefits

• Competitive salary based on experience
• Comprehensive benefits package including health insurance, dental/vision, 401(k) with match, paid time off
• Supportive team environment
• Hybrid work option

What This Job Offers

• Job Type: Full-time
• Career Level: Manager