Manager, Workers Compensation Claims

PetSmart•Phoenix, AZ
•Hybrid

About The Position

The Manager, Workers’ Compensation Claims oversees PetSmart’s multi-state workers’ compensation program and serves as the primary operational contact for the third-party administrator (TPA). The role monitors claim handling, regulatory compliance, reserves, litigation, service levels, claim trends, and cost performance. The TPA remains responsible for claim adjusting; the Manager provides program oversight, accountability, and direction. The Manager leads claim reviews and audits, addresses escalated issues, evaluates TPA performance, and provides reporting and recommendations to the Director, Risk Management. The position also provides day-to-day direction, coaching, and work prioritization to internal claims-support personnel, including the Workers’ Compensation Claims Specialist, and partners with Legal, Human Resources, Safety, Operations, Finance, and store leadership. The role is based at PetSmart’s Phoenix Home Office. Associates are expected to work in the office at least four days each week and may work up to one remote flex day in a standard work week with leader approval. The position requires collaboration and face-to-face interaction with colleagues, leaders, and/or clients.

Requirements

  • Five or more years of experience in workers’ compensation claims, insurance, risk management, or a related field, including at least two years overseeing adjusters, claim teams, or a third-party administrator.
  • Experience managing or overseeing multi-state workers’ compensation claims for a large employer, retailer, distributor, self-insured organization, or large-deductible program.
  • Demonstrated experience reviewing claim files, reserves, settlement recommendations, litigation activity, and claim-handling performance.
  • Working knowledge of the workers’ compensation claims lifecycle and ability to identify issues requiring escalation under applicable state requirements and company procedures.
  • Experience working directly with third-party claims administrators and holding vendors accountable to service standards and corrective-action plans.
  • Strong analytical, organizational, written, verbal communication, judgment, and problem-solving skills.
  • Ability to interpret claims reports, identify trends, and communicate recommendations clearly to operational and executive audiences.
  • Ability to manage multiple priorities while maintaining accuracy, confidentiality, and appropriate handling of employee medical and claim information.
  • Bachelor’s degree in risk management, business, insurance, finance, human resources, or a related field, or equivalent combination of education and experience.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience working with a third-party claims administrator.
  • Experience in a retail, distribution, or other multi-site operating environment.
  • Experience with claims-management systems, Microsoft Excel, and claims reporting or analytics tools.
  • AIC, ARM, CPCU, or comparable insurance or risk-management designation.
  • Workers’ compensation adjuster license or ability to obtain applicable licenses, where required by the position or state law.

Responsibilities

  • Oversee day-to-day administration of PetSmart’s workers’ compensation claims program across multiple states.
  • Serve as the primary operational contact for the TPA and establish regular claim-review and performance-review processes.
  • Lead reviews of open, litigated, high-exposure, delayed, and aged claims with TPA adjusters and management.
  • Monitor TPA compliance with applicable workers’ compensation requirements, contractual service standards, claim-handling procedures, and PetSmart expectations.
  • Review claim investigations, compensability and liability recommendations, reserve changes, settlement evaluations, medical management, and other material claim activity; escalate matters outside established authority or requiring management attention.
  • Track adjuster performance, claim-handling timeliness, file quality, required action items, and corrective-action plans, and work with the TPA to resolve service issues.
  • Partner with Legal and outside counsel on litigated claims, settlement recommendations, litigation reporting, and claim strategy; Legal retains responsibility for legal strategy.
  • Analyze claim data to identify trends by state, store, business unit, injury type, and other relevant categories, and recommend practical loss-control and process improvements.
  • Prepare recurring reports on claim inventory, paid and incurred losses, reserves, litigation, claim closure, claim frequency and severity, and TPA performance.
  • Partner with Human Resources, Safety, Operations, Finance, and store leadership on incident reporting, claim escalation, employee communications, and return-to-work coordination.
  • Maintain accurate claim records, reporting, controls, and documentation while protecting confidential employee, medical, and claim information.
  • Provide day-to-day direction, coaching, and work prioritization to internal claims-support personnel, including the Workers’ Compensation Claims Specialist.
  • Support claims, TPA, insurance-program, and financial audits; renewals; vendor reviews; system implementations; and other risk-management projects.

Benefits

  • Pet-friendly workplace where associates can bring pets to work, with an on-site dog park.
  • On-site events and adoption days, seasonal celebrations, family events, art events, and holiday festivals.
  • On-site gym with equipment, fitness classes, massage therapists, personal trainers, and wellness spaces.
  • On-site café serving breakfast, lunch, and snacks.
  • On-site NAEYC-accredited childcare facility providing early education.
  • Paid volunteer opportunities.
  • Print Center and Business Services, dry cleaning, Mother’s Rooms, and sustainable infrastructure.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service