Manager, Staff Counsel

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.•Princeton, NJ

About The Position

As a direct report to the Director, the Manager, Staff Counsel provides direction and monitors results of Staff Counsel. The role establishes long- and short-term business and litigation strategy and plans with the Leadership team, maintains a solid understanding of AmTrust’s mission, vision, and values, and upholds the organization’s standards. The position oversees litigation activity and team operations, provides legal guidance and practical advice to Claims and business partners, and leads and develops attorneys and staff. It also uses case data and performance metrics to inform decisions, supports goal setting and organizational initiatives, and ensures adherence to legal, ethical, regulatory, and litigation standards. The job description provides a general overview rather than a comprehensive list of duties; AmTrust may revise it at any time.

Requirements

  • Juris Doctor from an accredited law school.
  • Licensed attorney admitted to a State Bar.
  • Seven or more years in the practice of law, with first-chair experience litigating insurance-related cases or experience with an insurance company in a litigation leadership position.
  • Experience supervising attorneys.
  • Advanced understanding of litigation strategy and execution for multiple lines of insurance.
  • Embrace change, invite feedback related to performance, and deal constructively with criticism.
  • Proven track record of earning and keeping the trust of clients and colleagues.
  • Ability to persuade and influence within the company by presenting a strong case, explaining things clearly, challenging ideas effectively, and arguing in favor of one’s point of view.
  • Entrepreneurial spirit and customer focus, demonstrated by courage to pursue new and unprecedented opportunities.
  • Ability to synthesize and draw conclusions from large amounts of data and translate the data into actions and results.
  • Emotional intelligence and self-awareness.

Nice To Haves

  • Multi-state Bar admittance.
  • Experience with enterprise legal matter management platforms.

Responsibilities

  • Demonstrate strong command of applicable law and litigation practices; provide guidance on case strategy and legal issues; and ensure quality and consistency of work product.
  • Oversee the day-to-day litigation activity of the assigned team, ensuring files are actively managed with clear strategies and timely execution.
  • Provide timely and practical legal advice to Claims and business partners, supporting decision-making with clear analysis.
  • Engage in day-to-day operations, ensure workflows and initiatives are executed effectively, and support implementation of office strategy.
  • Review case data and performance metrics to inform decisions and provide objective insights into case and team performance.
  • Lead and supervise attorneys and staff; foster accountability, collaboration, and communication; and set clear expectations.
  • Support the selection, onboarding, and development of team members; provide regular feedback and coaching.
  • Build strong relationships with Claims, peers, and business partners; share insights and lessons learned.
  • Support goal setting aligned to litigation and business strategy and ensure team execution against objectives.
  • Navigate internal networks effectively and support the team in understanding organizational dynamics.
  • Ensure adherence to legal, ethical, and regulatory standards and monitor compliance with litigation guidelines.
  • Maintain awareness of legal, regulatory, and market trends and apply learnings to daily work.
  • Promote a culture of trust, transparency, and accountability and support a positive team environment.
  • Participate in departmental initiatives and support the implementation of changes and improvements.
  • Perform other functionally related duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Competitive compensation package.
  • Career advancement opportunities.
  • Medical plans.
  • Dental plans.
  • Life insurance, including eligible spouses and children.
  • Health Care Flexible Spending.
  • Dependent Care.
  • 401(k) savings plans.
  • Paid Time Off.

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Manager

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service