Fair Futures Program Supervisor

POLICE ATHLETIC LEAGUE INCNew York, NY
$75,000 - $77,000Hybrid

About The Position

Fair Futures is a youth-led advocacy movement and coalition of 100+ organizations advocating for young people who are system-involved in New York City to have access to the individualized supports they need to achieve their potential. Fair Futures is also a comprehensive model that includes a middle school program that prepares students for success in high school and a coaching program where young people ages 14+ are matched with a full-time, professionally trained Coach. Coaches provide emotional support to young people, believe in them, and help them with their academic, career development, housing, and life goals. The Supervisor’s overall job is to help create a strength-based, trauma-informed environment and provide ongoing management, direction, and support to up to 4-5 Coaches in building relationships with young people and helping them progress towards their goals. To achieve this, Coach Supervisors perform a variety of supervision and management daily duties. However, the work changes often according to the needs of the young people served by the Coach Supervisor’s team.

Requirements

  • A minimum of 2 years supervisory experience
  • Bachelor’s degree; Master’s preferred
  • Proven track record of successfully leading a team or teams, fostering a healthy workplace culture and evidence of positive programmatic impact made
  • Experience reading reports related to programmatic data, including the competency to use a data reporting platform
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills
  • Responsible, friendly, enthusiastic, patient, and actively engaged.
  • Able to follow directions and adhere to all policies and procedures.
  • Able to work collaboratively in a team environment.
  • Able to travel throughout the five boroughs of New York City.

Responsibilities

  • Model Behavior: The Supervisor should build trusting relationships with Coaches, as Coaches do with young people, and model a strength-based approach in their work.
  • Coach And Support Coaches In Their Work With Young People: Support Coaches in their efforts to build authentic, trusting relationships with young people, including sharing effective engagement techniques; Support Coaches in building relationships with the young people’s families and other key adults in their lives; Guide Coaches to use Motivational Interviewing techniques and the Fair Futures Coaching Language framework to develop and follow action plans with young people; Support Coaches with the academic and career development goal-setting process, including walking through how to use the process maps and dashboards, and selecting goals based on that young person’s situation in the online platform; Help Coaches navigate the DOE and other systems, as needed; Help Coaches prevent and navigate crises, as they arise.
  • Coach Supervision: Supervisors monitor the progress Coaches are making with young people through regular supervision sessions (typically weekly) and ensure Coaches are taking appropriate steps to help young people progress and plan for the next step on their journey. To prepare for supervision, the Supervisor should review key data in advance (including any progress notes, new academic data, and goals/steps completed over the last week). During the session, the Supervisor can debrief with Coaches on the status of their relationship with young people, any crisis situations, goal-setting progress, etc.
  • Provide Professional Development To Coaches: Acknowledge and celebrate Coaches’ strengths and progress; Identify areas for growth; Provide appropriate skill development opportunities; Conduct team meetings with Coaches and facilitate relevant conversations, such as: Best-practice engagement and coaching techniques; Shared challenges across the team Upcoming events, training, and/or group activities.
  • Meeting with young people and assigning Coaches;
  • Holding consistent, formal supervision with Coaches and Specialists;
  • Matching young people to new Coaches, as needed;
  • Working collaboratively with other professionals, such as staff, school administrators, guidance counselors, etc., as needed;
  • Participating in all Coach hiring;
  • Working collaboratively with other staff and system providers driving towards similar goals in a coordinated fashion;
  • Helping staff facilitate peer groups, which can focus on skills such as healthy communication, positive peer relationships, dealing with peer pressure, and service learning;
  • Working with the Program Director to conduct outreach to outside community agencies and provide direction to all program staff;
  • Ensuring that administrative and financial procedures are in place.

Benefits

  • health insurance
  • PTO
  • an employee assistance program
  • training
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service