Development Operations & Stewardship Specialist

Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges Inc•Livingston, NJ
•$65,000 - $75,000•Hybrid

About The Position

The Development Operations & Stewardship Specialist maintains accurate and useful fundraising records for the Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges. The position works primarily in the donor database and supports gift processing, donor-record maintenance, revenue reconciliation with Finance, reporting, campaign technology, pledge collection, acknowledgments, and stewardship. The Specialist partners with the Chief Development Officer, Directors of Development, branch leaders, and Finance to record gifts according to donor intent, maintain database integrity, support donor pipeline development, and provide reliable information to staff and volunteers. This is an individual-contributor role with no direct reports. The position serves as the primary administrator for the donor database and integrated development tools, manages data quality and integrations, supports staff users, and helps evaluate and implement technology. It also carries out stewardship communications and recognition, prepares campaign and donor reports, and supports development events. All employees must comply with child safety and abuse-prevention policies, training and reporting requirements, and the YMCA’s quality and member-service standards. The role is full-time, exempt, hybrid, based at Association Services, and requires 20% travel. Occasional evening and weekend work may be needed for events, campaigns, and year-end activities.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in nonprofit management, business, information systems, or a related field, or an equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • Minimum of 2–3 years of experience in gift processing, donor database management, or development operations in a nonprofit setting.
  • Hands-on experience and working knowledge of donor database platforms such as Raiser’s Edge NXT, Salesforce NPSP, Bloomerang, DonorPerfect, Give Butter, or a comparable system, including queries, imports/exports, and report building.
  • Strong understanding of gift processing, pledge and recurring gift management, fund restrictions, and IRS gift acknowledgment and substantiation requirements.
  • Intermediate to advanced Excel skills, including sorting, filtering, pivot tables, and lookups.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft 365.
  • Exceptional attention to detail and accuracy, with the ability to manage competing deadlines, especially at calendar and fiscal year-end.
  • Clear written and verbal communication skills and the ability to explain data to non-technical staff and volunteers.
  • Commitment to handling confidential donor information with discretion and integrity.
  • Successful completion of Metro Y child abuse prevention training, including Praesidium online training, within the required timeframe after hire.
  • Ability to sit or stand for extended periods while working at a computer, sustain attention to detail, and communicate effectively in person, by phone, video, and email.
  • Ability to travel locally to Metro Y branches, donor events, and meetings, including occasional evenings and weekends.
  • Ability to lift and carry materials up to 25 pounds.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience with online giving and event platforms.
  • Experience with mail merge.
  • Experience with data visualization or dashboard tools.

Responsibilities

  • Process gifts, pledges, pledge payments, recurring and online gifts, matching gifts, in-kind gifts, stock gifts, tribute gifts, and soft credits within two business days while honoring designations and restrictions.
  • Generate acknowledgments, tax receipts, and year-end giving statements; route selected gifts for personal thanks; and comply with IRS substantiation and quid pro quo disclosure requirements.
  • Prepare gift batches and deposit documentation, maintain supporting gift records, and assist with audit documentation.
  • Reconcile development revenue with Finance monthly and at fiscal year-end, research discrepancies, and prepare accounting journal entries for platform transactions.
  • Coordinate with Finance and the Chief Development Officer to establish funds, campaigns, and appeals; track restricted gifts and pledge balances; and develop procedures for non-standard gifts.
  • Administer the donor database and integrated development software, including system configuration, user roles, permissions, upgrades, and feature rollouts.
  • Manage data imports, exports, and integrations among donor, online giving, event, membership, and finance systems; troubleshoot synchronization errors and data discrepancies.
  • Assess technology needs and recommend, select, and implement tools and process improvements; lead system implementation, conversion, and data migration projects; and manage vendors, support escalations, and license renewals within the approved budget.
  • Maintain donor records and data integrity through audits, duplicate merges, address updates, and maintenance of contact details, relationships, codes, preferences, assignments, biographies, capacity ratings, segmentation, and deceased and do-not-solicit flags.
  • Follow and help document data entry standards and coding structures, and recommend procedure improvements for Chief Development Officer approval.
  • Support database users by providing basic training, maintaining user guides, coordinating vendor support, and processing access requests with Chief Development Officer approval.
  • Protect donor information under Metro Y privacy and security policies, the Donor Bill of Rights, and applicable PCI standards.
  • Carry out the donor stewardship calendar, coordinating pledge collection, thank-you communications, impact reports, donor updates, and recognition touchpoints with development colleagues.
  • Prepare and proofread donor recognition listings for reports, honor rolls, giving societies, events, campaigns, and capital campaign donor walls; provide recognition roles to branches annually and upon request.
  • Support moves management by maintaining contact reports, proposals, next steps, portfolio assignments, donor follow-up, open action items, and upcoming pledge-payment reminders.
  • Produce lapsed, LYBUNT/SYBUNT, first-time, and upgrade-ready donor reports to support renewal and retention outreach.
  • Assist the Chief Development Officer and Development Team with pipeline development and donor identification and qualification using database, capacity, news, and giving data.
  • Produce weekly and monthly campaign, Annual Support Campaign, retention, pledge-balance, and board-giving reports; maintain dashboards and flag trends or data issues.
  • Prepare segmented lists and queries for appeals, events, mailings, and email campaigns, and respond to staff and volunteer data requests.
  • Prepare data for YMCA of the USA, grant, audit, and other required reporting, ensuring consistency with Finance records.
  • Support development events with registration data, attendee lists, and post-event gift processing; attend select events, including occasional evenings and weekends.
  • Follow child abuse prevention policies, complete required training, maintain professional boundaries, make mandated reports, report concerns, and cooperate with investigations.
  • Demonstrate YMCA core values and member-service standards; follow safety and operating procedures; maintain required credentials and confidential records; report hazards and incidents; and participate in meetings, training, evaluation, and quality improvement.
  • Perform other related duties as assigned.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service