Customer Care Supervisor

Pinnacle Propane, LLC•Midland, TX
•Onsite

About The Position

Pinnacle Propane is seeking a Customer Care Supervisor in Marble Falls, Texas. The supervisor is accountable for the day-to-day performance, quality, and service delivery of a team of Customer Care Representatives across assigned service centers or branches. The role ensures that customer calls, orders, and inquiries are handled promptly, professionally, and accurately. The supervisor leads and develops team members, works closely with field Territory Directors to maintain local presence and community engagement, and collaborates with the Customer Care Program team on quality assurance and continuous process improvement. The position combines hands-on customer service with leadership, coaching, data-driven performance management, and a commitment to excellent customer experience. It is full-time during standard operating hours, with some travel within the assigned area to support service centers and branch teams.

Requirements

  • High school diploma or GED.
  • 4–5 years of customer service experience with increasing responsibility, ideally including experience managing or leading direct reports.
  • Ability to train, coach, and motivate team members to deliver high-quality customer service.
  • Effective communication skills and ability to interact professionally with employees, customers, and vendors.
  • Ability to resolve customer and employee inquiries calmly, professionally, and empathetically.
  • Strong organizational skills and attention to detail in a fast-paced, growth-oriented environment.
  • Strong computer skills, including proficiency in Microsoft Office.
  • Fluent written and verbal English.
  • Strong experience using AI-enabled tools.
  • Ability to travel within the assigned area as needed to support service centers and branch teams.

Nice To Haves

  • Associate or bachelor's degree.
  • Experience with ERP systems, RCC, and/or Salesforce.
  • Knowledge of Spanish.

Responsibilities

  • Manage the day-to-day performance of Customer Care Representatives and ensure customer inquiries—including orders, onboarding, payment and billing questions, scheduling, complaints, and walk-in traffic—are handled and routed accurately and promptly.
  • Be accountable for call-answer goals, including 95% of calls answered within 30 seconds, first-call resolution, and overall service levels.
  • Review daily, weekly, and monthly performance metrics with representatives and the Customer Care Manager, and set measurable expectations.
  • Anticipate staffing needs, create and adjust schedules, and ensure adherence to scheduled hours, including seasonal peak periods.
  • Address performance issues, coach team members, and support corrective action when necessary.
  • Back up the team by answering calls and handling inquiries during high call volume or staffing shortages.
  • Handle escalated customer complaints and track, analyze, and resolve critical issues.
  • Partner with field Territory Directors and Operations Managers to support local presence, community involvement, and alignment between branches and the customer care team.
  • Monitor adherence to department policies, procedures, and service standards across phone, email, and walk-in channels.
  • Identify recurring service issues and work with Customer Care Program leadership to address root causes and improve the customer experience.
  • Support key accounts and high-priority service requests to help meet order, delivery, and service commitments.
  • Identify and deliver training for representatives, including new-hire onboarding and continuing education on systems, products, and customer service practices.
  • Partner with Customer Care Program leadership on quality assurance, call monitoring and scoring, and process improvement projects.
  • Monitor compliance with company policies, data privacy standards, and applicable regulatory requirements related to customer interactions and billing.
  • Use CRM, ERP, and telephony/reporting systems, such as RCC and Salesforce, to track productivity, quality, and customer satisfaction.
  • Communicate regularly with the Customer Care Manager and District Managers about team performance, customer trends, and improvement opportunities.

Benefits

  • Medical insurance.
  • Vision insurance.
  • Dental insurance.
  • Life insurance.
  • Paid community volunteering day.
  • Generous paid time off.
  • Company holidays.
  • Retirement savings plan with employer contributions.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service