Controller and Finance Manager

Mahler Private Staffing•Milwaukee, WI
•Onsite

About The Position

The Controller and Finance Manager will oversee core accounting functions and serve as a key financial partner to the owner and management team. The role combines hands-on accounting leadership with financial analysis, budgeting, and communication of business insights to support operational decision-making. Reporting to the owner and management team, this position supervises the Senior Staff Accountant and is responsible for timely, accurate financial reporting. The successful candidate can review accounting details while understanding broader business context and translating financial results into actionable operational recommendations. This is an on-site role in downtown Milwaukee. The posting describes the position as full-time or part-time (32 hours per week) and offers compensation up to $150,000, commensurate with experience. The company operates in the staffing and real estate agency sectors.

Requirements

  • At least 5 years of experience in accounting leadership, financial reporting, budgeting, and financial analysis.
  • Ability to oversee accounting processes while providing business-focused financial insight.
  • Strong communication skills, including the ability to present financial results clearly to ownership and management.
  • Ability to identify issues, explain financial implications, and recommend practical operational improvements.
  • Experience supervising accounting staff or providing meaningful review and guidance to accounting team members.
  • Strong attention to detail and sound judgment.
  • Ability to balance hands-on execution with strategic analysis.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience with employee benefits, including 401(k) plans and insurance.
  • Experience with information technology.
  • Experience with incentive compensation plans.
  • CPA credential preferred but not required.

Responsibilities

  • Oversee the month-end close process to ensure timely, accurate, and complete financial reporting.
  • Review accounting activity prepared by the Senior Staff Accountant and provide guidance, oversight, and follow-through.
  • Understand monthly financial results, including performance drivers, unusual activity, and relevant trends.
  • Review and present the monthly financial reporting package to the owner and management team.
  • Support clear and consistent financial reporting to inform management decisions.
  • Prepare budgets in coordination with ownership and the management team.
  • Compare actual results to budget and prior expectations, identifying variances and operational implications.
  • Explain financial trends, cost drivers, revenue performance, and areas requiring attention.
  • Provide financial input for planning, resource allocation, and operational priorities.
  • Analyze financial results and identify meaningful business insights.
  • Recommend operational changes based on financial analysis and business performance.
  • Partner with ownership and management to evaluate opportunities to improve efficiency, profitability, and accountability.
  • Present financial information concisely and practically to financial and non-financial stakeholders.
  • Serve as an internal resource for accounting, reporting, budgeting, and financial performance questions.
  • Supervise, support, and direct the Senior Staff Accountant, promoting accuracy, accountability, and timely completion of responsibilities.
  • Communicate expectations clearly and follow up on deliverables professionally and constructively.
  • Collaborate with ownership, management, and internal team members.
  • Partner with HR and senior leadership on the development, evaluation, and administration of company-wide compensation plans, incentive structures, bonus programs, and workforce budgeting.
  • Oversee payroll operations and provide financial analysis and oversight of compensation, benefits, retirement plan costs, and other employee-related expenditures.
  • Collaborate with HR on internal controls, policies, procedures, and employment-related compliance matters, partnering with outside employment counsel as appropriate.
  • Evaluate benefit plan costs, vendor contracts, and renewals, identifying cost-efficiency opportunities while maintaining competitive employee benefits.

Benefits

  • Health insurance
  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Paid time off
  • Paid holidays
  • Employer-paid short-term disability insurance
  • Employer-paid long-term disability insurance
  • Life insurance
  • 401(k) retirement plan with safe harbor match
  • Paid indoor garage parking
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service