Commercial Appraisal Reviewer III

First Financial Bank•Cincinnati, OH

About The Position

Commercial Appraisal Reviewers review third-party appraisal reports for commercial lending. They also review environmental reports and may review appraisal reports for residential mortgage loans, consumer loans, and consumer collections. The role includes engaging appraisal, evaluation, and environmental services as needed. The reviewer manages valuation work from engagement through review, including vendor communications, delivery timelines, discrepancy resolution, and revisions. They review appraisals and evaluations across property types and value levels for supportability, credibility, and compliance with applicable regulations, USPAP, FIRREA, bank policies and procedures, and industry standards. The role handles the highest-value and most complex properties, may perform independent analysis to develop a value indication, and works independently with minimal supervision. The reviewer also supports department procedures, staff development, quality control, and process improvements.

Requirements

  • General commercial appraisal certification.
  • Professional designation, or advanced candidacy for designation, from an appraisal organization such as AI, NAIFA, or ASA.
  • Bachelor’s degree or an equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • Five years of experience in commercial property appraisal, commercial appraisal review, commercial collateral underwriting, and/or commercial property analysis and market conditions.
  • Ability to analyze complex commercial appraisal and evaluation reports and communicate review results effectively.
  • Ability to interpret environmental assessment reports and communicate findings.
  • Ability to define problems, collect data, establish facts, and draw valid conclusions, and to identify and escalate critical issues promptly.
  • Ability to adapt to policy and process changes, learn independently, collaborate as part of a team, multitask, manage challenging situations, and meet deadlines.
  • Strong analytical skills, including the ability to work with complex mathematical concepts.
  • Fluency in appraisal terminology and strong understanding of appraisal methodologies and concepts.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office, web browsers, and video conferencing systems.
  • Effective written and oral communication skills with internal and external business partners, including responding to inquiries or complaints and providing viable solutions when appropriate.
  • Ability to comply with applicable laws, regulations, and bank policies, including Bank Secrecy Act, Anti-Money Laundering, OFAC, suspicious activity reporting, and other lending and deposit compliance requirements.
  • Ability to learn using written procedures, verbal instruction, and webinar videos.

Nice To Haves

  • Appraisal or review experience with a variety of property types.
  • Experience with complex and specialty properties, such as LIHTC, health care, hotel, or special-use properties.
  • Experience with YouConnect/Glances or a similar appraisal management platform.
  • Technology proficiency to investigate and implement enhancements to systems in use.
  • Prior appraisal review experience or experience with a lending institution.
  • Knowledge of federal regulatory requirements.
  • Knowledge of agency and partnership requirements, including FNMA, FHLMC, SBA, and Farmer Mac.
  • Technical writing skills for developing or updating department procedures and job aids, and the ability to lead and present them.

Responsibilities

  • Review appraisal and evaluation reports for all property types and value levels to assess whether market values are reasonably supported, credible, and compliant with regulations, USPAP, FIRREA, bank policies and procedures, and industry standards.
  • Manage valuation work from end to end, including engaging vendors, communicating to ensure timely report delivery, resolving discrepancies, obtaining revisions, and serving as the liaison between vendors and the bank.
  • Review environmental reports and communicate findings to ensure adherence to bank environmental policies and procedures.
  • Review appraisal reports that may relate to residential mortgage loans, consumer loans, and consumer collections.
  • Perform independent analysis and provide an independent value indication when warranted.
  • Assist the manager with developing and updating department procedures and present or deliver updates to the team.
  • Meet department turnaround-time expectations established through service-level agreements with lines of business.
  • Define scope parameters and identify appropriate vendors for valuation and environmental services.
  • Mentor and assist department staff, support quality control of internal reviews and file documentation, and identify or implement process improvements and efficiency opportunities.
  • Attend appraisal courses and seminars, develop relevant market knowledge, and learn and perform administrative tasks related to appraisal review.

Benefits

  • Benefits and programs supporting associates’ holistic wellbeing.
  • Incentive eligibility.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service