Claims Specialist III - MCU

UFG Insurance•,
•$103,000 - $136,000

About The Position

UFG is hiring a senior-level, technically advanced Claims Specialist III to work within its Complex Claims team. The role makes claim decisions and takes actions to provide high-quality, efficient, and cost-effective representation of insureds and UFG in complex, high-exposure litigated matters involving complex coverage issues. The position may also be responsible for technical large-loss management and reporting on assigned files. The position investigates, evaluates, negotiates, and resolves highly complex litigated casualty claims, including matters involving pollution, mass torts, BIPA, sexual harassment, employment practices, professional liability, class actions, and litigated coverage. It requires extensive litigated casualty claims experience, strong analytical and negotiation skills, and effective litigation management. The specialist conducts timely investigations, verifies coverage, selects and retains defense counsel, analyzes liability, evaluates damages for reserves and settlement, and applies claims best practices. The role calls for strong technical and interpersonal skills, effective communication, attention to detail, and the ability to manage multiple tasks. The specialist works independently with limited supervision and substantial accountability, while pursuing professional development. The position works remotely from home or in a general office environment; irregular hours are frequent, and occasional overnight travel and weekend hours may be required.

Requirements

  • At least 10 years of casualty claims experience.
  • Meet the applicable state licensing requirements for handling claims.
  • Ability to read, comprehend, and interpret policy language, endorsements, and contracts and apply them to claims.
  • Analytical ability to assess coverage, risk transfer, liability, and bodily injury/property damage for reserve and settlement evaluation.
  • Strong negotiation, interpersonal, analytical, organizational, oral communication, and written communication skills.
  • Ability to document information concisely in appropriate file notes and reports.
  • Strong negotiation skills with attorneys and effective mediation and arbitration techniques.
  • Ability to proactively manage defense counsel and expenses.
  • Service-oriented mindset, clear and concise communication, analytical and critical thinking, collaboration and curiosity, proactive decision-making and problem-solving, effective negotiation, time management, and a sense of service urgency.
  • Aptitude for mentorship and leadership, including mentoring and development.
  • Polished presentation skills and ability to present and articulate claims to a committee.

Nice To Haves

  • Bachelor’s degree preferred.
  • Law degree preferred.
  • CPCU, AIC, SCLA, Legal Principles, or AEI-series CCLA or PCLA designation preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Review new claim assignments to determine the nature of the claim and the action required.
  • Secure and review notice materials and, for litigated claims, the complaint to determine UFG’s obligations; draft coverage position letters when coverage issues arise.
  • Investigate primary claims and determine whether resolution should be attempted before assigning defense counsel.
  • Vet and retain defense counsel when there is a duty to defend.
  • Collaborate with defense counsel on case strategy and action plans, documented in litigation plans and budgets.
  • Manage claim files and defense counsel to carry out agreed plans and proactively move claims toward resolution.
  • Document file activity in detailed notes and prepare claim-file reports in accordance with best practices.
  • Evaluate damages and recommend reserves in accordance with timeliness and accuracy guidelines.
  • Develop and execute negotiation strategies to move claims toward resolution.
  • Identify subrogation potential and position claims for successful recovery.
  • Identify risk-transfer opportunities and exposures, draft tender letters, and notify potential responsible parties.
  • Work with defense counsel to vet, select, and retain experts as needed, while applying expense-management initiatives.
  • Notify insureds of key developments and demands, and communicate significant exposure changes to the agency and underwriting.
  • Review fee statements and negotiate adjustments in accordance with UFG billing guidelines.
  • For litigated coverage files, retain and manage outside coverage counsel; vet coverage positions for declaratory judgment actions and escalate issues to in-house legal as needed.
  • Evaluate coverage issues and communicate declaratory judgment developments to the underlying adjuster and management in coordination with outside coverage counsel.
  • Assist outside coverage counsel by obtaining necessary file materials and supporting discovery responses.
  • Inform underwriting of increased hazards or unusual circumstances involving a risk or policy exposure.
  • Participate in company-sponsored and other educational opportunities to develop knowledge and skills.
  • Participate in claims committees to advance claims initiatives.
  • Support the team through adaptability, sharing improvement ideas, pursuing professional development, and collaborating with peers.
  • Mentor other Claim Specialists and provide technical training to their teams.
  • Serve as a subject-matter expert in coverage analysis, risk transfer, additional insured matters and tenders, liability analysis, reserve and settlement evaluation, negotiation, and defense strategy.

Benefits

  • Annual incentive compensation.
  • Medical, dental, vision, and life insurance.
  • Accident, critical illness, and short-term disability insurance.
  • Retirement plans with employer contributions.
  • Generous time-off program.
  • Programs designed to support employee well-being and financial security.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service