Claims Analyst

Acrisure•Middleton, WI
•$55,000 - $56,000•Onsite

About The Position

The Claims Analyst independently adjudicates multi-state workers’ compensation indemnity, employer’s liability (EL), and subrogation claim files that are generally non-catastrophic. The role manages claims from coverage verification and initial investigation through benefit delivery, return-to-work coordination, litigation, settlement, and recovery. It also maintains claim documentation and reserves, supports client relationships, and coordinates with internal and external parties.

Requirements

  • Professional telephone demeanor and strong verbal, written, and listening skills.
  • Strong organizational skills.
  • Thorough knowledge of workers’ compensation claims procedures and policies.
  • Strong understanding of human nature and motivation principles.
  • Ability to handle problem issues under stress and amid conflict or adversity.
  • Computer literacy, including strong familiarity with Microsoft Office Suite.
  • Ability to type 45 WPM.
  • Basic understanding of business technology.
  • Responsiveness to changing business needs.
  • Ability to work under pressure, multitask in a fast-paced environment, and maintain attention to detail.
  • Ability to adhere to ethical conduct and fair claims settlement practices.
  • Ability to take direction and make decisions.
  • Ability to learn procedures quickly and adapt to a changing environment.
  • Ability to work in a team environment and with limited supervision.
  • Ability to use close, distance, and color vision.
  • Minimum education of a high school diploma or bachelor’s degree, and/or 2–5 years of similar experience.
  • Relevant state licensing, or the ability to obtain licensing.

Nice To Haves

  • Litigation experience.

Responsibilities

  • Receive lost-time assignments and verify coverage and its applicability.
  • Complete contact within 24 hours with the employer, employee, and attending physician, including telephonic contact, recorded statements, and/or in-person interviews with insureds, employees, physicians, and witnesses.
  • Review coverage issues and determine compensability within Midwest standards.
  • Manage all aspects of workers’ compensation claims, including litigation, and provide direction to defense counsel.
  • Establish and maintain client trust through regular contact, prompt responses, and resolution of client questions and claim issues.
  • Set reserves to Ultimate Probable Cost (UPC) and for anticipated exposure, subject to authority limits.
  • Ensure timely benefit delivery, including required benefit notices to injured parties.
  • Coordinate return to work in accordance with the injured worker’s medical disability plan.
  • Document claim files properly in the claims system and maintain an active diary in 30-day intervals.
  • Negotiate settlements directly with injured workers or opposing counsel.
  • Consider Medicare’s interests, including conditional payments and injured workers’ eligibility, in settlements.
  • Identify and manage third-party liability and subrogation through recovery.
  • Review medical and expense bills for causal relationship and charges over $1,500.
  • Consult with a Claim Supervisor, Claims Manager, or Executive Claims when assistance is needed.
  • Complete claim status reports.
  • Assign nurse case management when indicated and monitor billing and performance.
  • Coordinate claim review meetings with internal and external parties.
  • Attend hearings and depositions when required.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Comprehensive medical insurance
  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Life and disability insurance
  • Fertility benefits
  • Wellness resources
  • Paid sick time
  • Generous paid time off and holidays
  • Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
  • Complimentary Calm app subscription
  • Immediate vesting in a 401(k) plan
  • Health Savings Account (HSA) and Flexible Spending Account (FSA) options
  • Commuter benefits
  • Employee discount programs
  • Paid maternity leave
  • Paid paternity leave, including for adoptive parents
  • Legal plan options
  • Pet insurance
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service