Property Manager (Single-Family Property Management)
About The Position
T&H Realty Services is seeking a Property Manager with deep experience in investor-focused property management to oversee a high-value portfolio (350-450 homes) in Central Indiana. This role is ideal for a seasoned professional who thrives in client-facing leadership, complex portfolios, and structured operating environments. What You’ll Own Full responsibility for an extensive residential portfolio, acting as the primary client concierge and trusted advisor Investor onboarding & relationship management, including expectation-setting and ongoing portfolio analysis Oversight of property turnovers, security deposit finalization, and dispute resolution Cross-functional coordination with maintenance, accounting, leasing, and resident relations teams Proactive communication during high-impact periods (turnover, leasing, escalations) What We’re Looking For 5–10+ years of property management, asset management, or real estate investment experience Strong understanding of Indiana landlord-tenant laws and operational compliance Proven success managing high-volume or complex portfolios Investor-minded approach with the ability to discuss ROI, performance, and strategy Excellent communication, judgment, and ownership mentality Role Details Schedule: Full-time, Monday–Friday, 8:30 AM–5:00 PM Location: Hybrid (home office + Indianapolis corporate office) Benefits Competitive compensation (experience-based) Health, dental, and vision insurance PTO & Simple IRA retirement plan Annual bonus program Housing discount (where applicable) 📩 Apply with resume and salary requirements. T&H Realty Services is an Equal Opportunity Employer. Learn more at www.threaltyinc.com
Requirements
- 5–10+ years of property management, asset management, or real estate investment experience
- Strong understanding of Indiana landlord-tenant laws and operational compliance
- Proven success managing high-volume or complex portfolios
- Investor-minded approach with the ability to discuss ROI, performance, and strategy
- Excellent communication, judgment, and ownership mentality
Responsibilities
- Full responsibility for an extensive residential portfolio, acting as the primary client concierge and trusted advisor
- Investor onboarding & relationship management, including expectation-setting and ongoing portfolio analysis
- Oversight of property turnovers, security deposit finalization, and dispute resolution
- Cross-functional coordination with maintenance, accounting, leasing, and resident relations teams
- Proactive communication during high-impact periods (turnover, leasing, escalations)
Benefits
- Competitive compensation (experience-based)
- Health, dental, and vision insurance
- PTO & Simple IRA retirement plan
- Annual bonus program
- Housing discount (where applicable)
Stand Out From the Crowd
Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.
What This Job Offers
Job Type
Full-time
Career Level
Manager
Education Level
No Education Listed
Number of Employees
11-50 employees
