Claims Representative

Acuity • Sheboygan, WI

1d • $66,000 - $66,000 • Onsite

About The Position

Acuity is seeking a class of entry-level Claims Representatives to start in June 2026. Claims Reps investigate claims to determine specifics surrounding a property, auto or general liability claim. This includes phone contact with involved parties, as well as obtaining information via phone, fax and e-mail from agents, doctors, attorneys and other external parties involved in the claim. The claims investigation and evaluation process includes determining coverage under the insurance policy, evaluating liability, assessing damages, and forecasting reserves, while providing the best in class customer service. To learn more from our employees about what it's like to work in Claims at Acuity, click here! Internal Application Deadline: March 9, 2026 ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS: Proactively investigate, evaluate and resolve assigned multi-line property and liability claims within multiple state venues. Make timely and meaningful initial contact with parties involved in the claim, particularly claimants and insureds. Accurately evaluate policy coverage by applying claim facts to the policy contract terms. Consistently forecast reserves, by setting reserve initially with proper reserve coding and monitoring reserve adequacy throughout the course of the claim, consistent with Acuity’s reserve philosophy. Thoroughly investigate assigned claims by conducting phone interviews, obtaining recorded statements, securing photos, and obtaining written reports and/or documents. Maintain a personal follow-up task on all claim files to assure timely, proactive handling, efficient claim file organization, quality customer service, and proper management of pending claims. Accurate and thorough claim file documentation, to consist of timely entry of activity log entries, claims system screen updates, and imaged documentation. Identify potentially fraudulent claims and promptly refer suspect claims to the Special Investigations Unit (SIU). Participate in internal claims phone queue as assigned. Employ and manage outside vendor resources in a cost effective manner. Utilize sound judgment and discretion with settlement authority to properly and effectively resolve claims through negotiation, settlement or denial. Successfully manage litigation files according to company guidelines. Periodically participate in off-hours storm claims duty as dictated by storm claims volume. Maintain a positive, professional attitude. Engage in claims educational opportunities, both in-house and external, as sponsored by management. Always represent Acuity in a professional manner. Complete a mandatory training program as determined by Acuity. Regular and predictable attendance. Perform other duties as assigned.

Requirements

• College degree or equivalent relevant experience.
• Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
• Proven organizational and time management skills.
• Proficient in current computer technology.
• Ability and willingness to provide quality customer service.
• Strong analytical and creative problem solving abilities.
• Ability to work both independently and in collaboration with others.
• Acuity does not sponsor applicants for U.S. work authorization.

Nice To Haves

• Customer service or insurance experience preferred.
• Bilingual is a valuable competence.

Responsibilities

• Proactively investigate, evaluate and resolve assigned multi-line property and liability claims within multiple state venues.
• Make timely and meaningful initial contact with parties involved in the claim, particularly claimants and insureds.
• Accurately evaluate policy coverage by applying claim facts to the policy contract terms.
• Consistently forecast reserves, by setting reserve initially with proper reserve coding and monitoring reserve adequacy throughout the course of the claim, consistent with Acuity’s reserve philosophy.
• Thoroughly investigate assigned claims by conducting phone interviews, obtaining recorded statements, securing photos, and obtaining written reports and/or documents.
• Maintain a personal follow-up task on all claim files to assure timely, proactive handling, efficient claim file organization, quality customer service, and proper management of pending claims.
• Accurate and thorough claim file documentation, to consist of timely entry of activity log entries, claims system screen updates, and imaged documentation.
• Identify potentially fraudulent claims and promptly refer suspect claims to the Special Investigations Unit (SIU).
• Participate in internal claims phone queue as assigned.
• Employ and manage outside vendor resources in a cost effective manner.
• Utilize sound judgment and discretion with settlement authority to properly and effectively resolve claims through negotiation, settlement or denial.
• Successfully manage litigation files according to company guidelines.
• Periodically participate in off-hours storm claims duty as dictated by storm claims volume.
• Maintain a positive, professional attitude.
• Engage in claims educational opportunities, both in-house and external, as sponsored by management.
• Always represent Acuity in a professional manner.
• Complete a mandatory training program as determined by Acuity.
• Regular and predictable attendance.
• Perform other duties as assigned.

Benefits

• Acuity offers a comprehensive benefits package, including a generous 401(k) contribution, medical, dental, vision, life and disability insurance, paid time off, an Employee Assistance Program, and more.
• A full description of benefits and eligibility will be provided to candidates during the hiring process.

What This Job Offers

• Job Type: Full-time
• Career Level: Entry Level