Senior Bodily Injury Specialist

Plymouth Rock Assurance • Uniondale, NY

6d • $85,000 - $117,000

About The Position

Are you a seasoned claims professional ready to take your career to the next
level? Join our team and make a direct impact handling high-severity First- and
Third-Party Bodily Injury claims across both Personal Lines and Commercial
settings. This role’s primary responsibility is managing Massachusetts (MA)
casualty and bodily injury claims, with opportunities to support other states as
business needs arise. You will take ownership of complex, high-exposure cases
while helping shape claim outcomes for our policyholders and the company.

Requirements

• Bachelor’s degree from an accredited institution.
• Minimum 3–5 years handling bodily injury claims, preferably with complex liability claims experience (Commercial, UM/UIM, Excess/Umbrella).
• Deep knowledge of litigation, arbitration, and trial procedures, plus multi-state claim handling experience. This role will primarily involve losses in Massachusetts and New Hampshire, so experience in these states is preferred.
• Strong self-motivation, coverage analysis, investigation, and negotiation abilities.
• Sharp organizational, problem-solving, and interpersonal skills.
• Thorough understanding of state laws, regulatory guidelines, and statutory requirements.

Responsibilities

• Investigations with Impact – Conduct thorough coverage, liability, and injury investigations, securing statements to efficiently resolve claims.
• Master Policy Analysis – Navigate complex insurance policies, advising on Excess and Primary coverage matters.
• Lead Field Oversight – Direct field investigations and coordinate with vendors (Field/Counsel/Surveillance) to ensure effective claim resolutions.
• Strategic Reserve Management – Maintain financial oversight with accurate, timely reserve analyses based on claim developments.
• Litigation & Fraud Prevention – Collaborate with defense counsel, manage litigation strategies, and work with SIU to combat fraud.
• Skilled Negotiations – Resolve claims through merit-based discussions with injured parties and attorneys for favorable outcomes.
• Subrogation & Recovery – Identify and pursue subrogation opportunities to minimize losses.
• Legal Representation – Represent Plymouth Rock in arbitrations, depositions, mediations, and trials.
• Professional Growth & Leadership – Stay ahead of industry trends, participate in training, and contribute to team initiatives.

Benefits

• Paid time off
• Free onsite gym at our Boston location
• Tuition reimbursement
• Low cost and excellent health insurance coverage options that start on Day 1 (medical, dental, vision)
• Robust health and wellness programs
• Auto and home insurance discounts
• Matching donation opportunities
• Annual 401(k) employer contribution
• Various Paid Family leave options including Paid Parental Leave
• Resources to promote professional development
• Convenient locations and pre-tax commuter benefits

What This Job Offers

• Job Type: Full-time
• Career Level: Senior
• Number of Employees: 501-1,000 employees